Responding to a Schedule of Dilapidations: Evidence, Scott Schedules and Negotiation
Commercial Schedule of Dilapidations Advice

A Schedule of Dilapidations is not simply a contractor's work list or an invoice that a commercial tenant must accept. It is a set of allegations based on the lease, the condition of the property and the landlord's proposed remedy. A strong response tests each part of that case with evidence.
The highest headline cost is not always the landlord's recoverable loss, but dismissing the schedule without a structured response can weaken the tenant's position. Early coordination between the tenant, building surveyor and solicitor gives the team time to inspect, preserve records, assess works and manage the timetable.
Begin with the lease, not the total
The lease defines the contractual obligations. Review repairing, decorating, yielding-up, statutory compliance, access and reinstatement clauses, together with licences for alterations, side letters, rent deposit terms and any break conditions. A Schedule of Condition may limit an obligation only if its wording and incorporation into the lease have the required effect, so legal advice is essential.
The RICS consumer guide to dilapidations explains the main documents and the different interests of landlords and tenants. AMS SURVEYS provides dilapidations advice for commercial tenants throughout England and Wales, working alongside the client's legal advisers.
Preserve condition and alteration evidence
Inspect before strip-out, reinstatement or occupation changes remove evidence. Record every relevant area, including roofs, elevations, structure, services, finishes, external works and tenant alterations. Photographs should be dated, located and tied to a plan or schedule. General photographs without orientation or scale rarely answer a disputed allegation.
Compare the current condition with the original lease documents and any photographic Schedule of Condition. Gather completion records, maintenance logs, service reports, contractor invoices, licences for alterations and correspondence about known defects. The response should state when evidence is unavailable rather than filling gaps with assumptions.
Separate liability, remedy and cost
Each item should answer four questions. What covenant is relied upon? Does the observed condition amount to a breach? What work is reasonably required to remedy that breach? What cost or loss follows? A tenant may accept that an element is defective while disputing the proposed replacement, specification, quantity or cost.
Distinguish repair from improvement. Modern compliance, market expectations or the landlord's preferred upgrade may exceed the tenant's covenant. Conversely, a short-term patch may not be a reasonable repair where the lease requires the property to be yielded up in proper condition. Technical scope must remain tied to the wording of the lease and the facts on site.
Use the Scott Schedule as a live evidence document
A Scott Schedule allows the parties to work through the claim item by item. The tenant's surveyor can record admissions, denials, alternative remedies, quantities, rates and supporting evidence. Clear comments are more useful than repetitive phrases such as not accepted. Where an item depends on legal interpretation, mark it for the solicitor rather than presenting a technical opinion as legal advice.
Cross-reference the lease clause and the exact location of each alleged breach.
State whether the condition, liability, remedy, quantity or cost is disputed.
Attach photographs, drawings, test results and maintenance records where they add evidence.
Identify work already completed and provide invoices, specifications or completion records.
Record agreed items separately so negotiation can focus on genuine differences.
Consider the landlord's intentions and supersession
The landlord's intentions for the property matter. If the building is to be demolished, extensively redeveloped or refitted in a way that supersedes the claimed works, some alleged losses may not arise. This is a fact-sensitive legal and valuation issue, not an automatic defence. The tenant team should request a clear statement of intentions and test it against planning, design, letting and procurement evidence.
The RICS professional standard for dilapidations covers schedules, responses, costed documents, landlord intentions and diminution. The building surveyor should recognise when a specialist valuation opinion is needed because repair cost and recoverable loss are not always the same.
Price the correct scope
Cost evidence should use a defined scope, realistic quantities and rates appropriate to the property, location, access and programme. Include preliminaries, professional fees, statutory costs and VAT only where they are relevant and properly explained. Quotations are most useful when contractors price the same specification; otherwise the apparent comparison may hide different assumptions.
Where work may disturb asbestos-containing materials, follow the HSE guidance on arranging an asbestos survey. A standard management survey may not be sufficient before intrusive refurbishment or demolition work. The party controlling the work must ensure that the necessary information and survey scope are in place.
Manage protocol timing and communication
The Dilapidations Protocol applies to claims for damages concerning the physical state of commercial property at termination of a tenancy in England and Wales. It expects the landlord's schedule and Quantified Demand within a reasonable time, generally 56 days after termination, and usually allows the tenant 56 days to respond.
Do not let the timetable force a superficial answer. If information is missing, explain what is needed and agree a proportionate extension through the legal team where possible. Communications should be open enough to narrow issues without making unsupported admissions. Surveyor meetings and alternative dispute resolution can resolve technical differences before costs escalate.
Decide whether to do works or negotiate
Before lease expiry, a tenant may have the opportunity to complete works, but the decision needs planning. Confirm access, landlord approvals, statutory requirements, asbestos information, contractor availability and whether the proposed work will satisfy the covenant. Poorly scoped late work can consume cash without reducing the claim.
Our commercial lease exit timeline explains why preparation should begin well before the last day. Where expiry has passed, the response should focus on liability and the landlord's likely loss, supported by the Scott Schedule, cost evidence and legal advice.
Schedule of Dilapidations - Frequently asked questions
How should a tenant respond to a Schedule of Dilapidations?
Start by reviewing the lease, licences, Schedule of Condition and the landlord's allegations with a building surveyor and solicitor. Inspect the property, preserve evidence and respond item by item, usually through a Scott Schedule. The response should address liability, scope, cost and the landlord's likely loss rather than accepting or rejecting only the headline total.
What is a Scott Schedule in a dilapidations claim?
A Scott Schedule is the working document used to set out the landlord's allegations and the tenant's response against each item. It can record the lease clause, alleged breach, required remedy, cost, tenant comments and agreed or disputed position. It helps the parties narrow differences and keeps technical and financial reasoning transparent.
Does a tenant always have to pay the full cost of the works?
No. Liability depends on the lease, the property's condition, the evidence, the proper remedy and the landlord's actual loss. Proposed redevelopment, superseding works and statutory limits may reduce a claim. A building surveyor provides technical and cost evidence, while the tenant's solicitor advises on legal liability.
When should a tenant appoint a dilapidations surveyor?
Ideally, appoint a surveyor before lease expiry, when there is still time to inspect, budget, negotiate access and complete sensible work. If a schedule or Quantified Demand has already arrived, obtain advice promptly so evidence is preserved and protocol deadlines are managed with the legal team.
Turn the schedule of dilapidations into a managed decision
AMS SURVEYS advises commercial tenants across Liverpool, Manchester, Cheshire, Lancashire, North Wales, Leeds, Sheffield, Stoke and the wider UK. Send the lease, schedule, Quantified Demand, plans, Schedule of Condition and alteration records. We can scope an inspection and provide the technical evidence needed for a clear, item-by-item response.
%204K%20AMS%20SURVEYS%20LOGO.png)





